Which mascara is better imju fiberwig or givenchy phenomen eyes?

Fiberwig is great but gives no volume- only length. On the other hand Givenchy can clump quite easily. Both have a pro and con. |||fiberwig is better. the pheomen'eyes runs out really quickly and it smudges all over the place when you put it on. fiberwig goes on clean. no clumps, makes your lashes amazingly long and lasts all day. it's aso a little less expensive.